Published online before print April 3, 2008
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Laboratory of Innate Immunity, Center of Research Ste Justine Hospital, and Department of Microbiology and Immunology, University of Montreal, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
1Correspondence: Center of Research, Ste Justine Hospital, 3175 Côte Ste-Catherine, Montreal, Qc, H3T 1C5, Canada. E-mail: ali.ahmad{at}recherche-ste-justine.qc.ca
Key Words: CD94/NKG2 chemokines cytokines HIV-1 HLA KIR KIR haplotypes MHC class I MICA MICB NKG2D ULBP
NK cells constitute an important component of the hosts innate immune system. Once considered as relatively unimportant and nonspecific killers of tumor cells, NK cells are now recognized as important cells with ready-to-go effector and regulatory functions. For long, NK cells have been known to kill virus-infected cells, and NK cell-deficient individuals have been known to suffer from repeated viral and bacterial infections [2 , 3 ]. However, a lack of understanding of NK cell immunobiology until recent years has been an impediment in appreciating the role of these cells in controlling these infections. Today, scientists have made significant advances in understanding how NK cells function and regulate innate and adaptive immune responses. Consequently, we have learned a lot about the role of these cells in HIV and other viral infections. The review focuses on NK cell responses in HIV infections and their relevance to anti-HIV resistance, immunotherapy, and vaccination. We also underline some of the important unresolved issues with respect to these cells in HIV infection that need to be addressed in future research. Understandably, it will have to begin with an overview of the current immunobiology of NK cells.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 1. Common Markers Used for Phenotypic Characterization of Human NK Cells
|
β TCR and certain NK cell markers (CD56+, CD161+), and secrete IFN-
and/or IL-4. They recognize self and foreign glycolipids in association with a MHC class I-related glycoprotein CD1d. Activation of NKT cells usually leads to activation of NK cells and dendritic cells (DC) in the body.
Human NK cells can be divided into two major subsets based on the level of expression of CD56 and the presence or absence of CD16. The two markers are usually expressed reciprocally on these cells. The two subsets CD56highCD16– and CD56lowCD16+ represent
10% and 90% of NK cells present in the peripheral blood, respectively [8
, 9
]. The cells in the two subsets differ in their proliferative potential, homing characteristics, functional capabilities, and responses to different cytokines (listed in Table 2
). The cells in the former subset express high-affinity receptors for IL-2, proliferate in response to picomolar concentrations of the cytokine, produce mainly cytokines upon activation, and have low cytotoxic potential. They express little KIR and preferentially migrate to secondary lymphoid organs, e.g., lymph nodes, tonsils. Most of the NK cells in lymph nodes are CD56high. The CD56low CD16+ NK cells express low-affinity IL-2Rs, proliferate in response to nanomolar concentrations of IL-2, express KIR, and are highly cytotoxic. These NK cells migrate to inflamed tissues in response to chemotactic stimuli. By virtue of expression of CD16, they are also efficient mediators of ADCC. The CD56high subset is less cytotoxic as compared with the CD56low subset, probably as a result of their lower expression of perforin and
-chain [9
, 10
]. The
-chain is a signal-transducing component of the high-affinity receptor for IgE (Fc
RI) and acts as a signaling partner for several activating NK cell receptors (NKRs), e.g., CD16a, NKp30, NKp46, etc. Both NK cell subsets become potent killer cells upon incubation with cytokines and are called lymphokine-activated killer cells. Some workers also differentiate between CD16high and CD16dim subsets of NK cells. Furthermore, NK cells expressing CD56 and CD16 have also been described. They may represent different activation and differentiation states of NK cells. It is noteworthy that incubation with different cytokines may change phenotypic, functional, as well as homing characteristics of NK cells. For example, IL-2, IL-12, and IL-15 can convert CD56highCD16– and CD56lowCD16+ NK cell subsets into CD56brightCD16+ cells. On the other hand, TGF-β1 converts CD16+ NK cells into CD16– NK cells [11
12
13
].
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 2. Characteristics of Two Major NK Cell Subsets
|
-defensins: the antimicrobial peptides that can disrupt bacterial cell walls. They act as important immunoregulatory cells by secreting cytokines and chemokines. It is noteworthy that NK cells are the only known source of IFN-
other than activated T cells. The cytokine is known to activate macrophages and drive CD4+ T cell differentiation into type 1 (TH1) cells. It also induces expression of TRAIL on T cells. An immediate release of this cytokine from NK cells in early stages of an infection is crucial for inducing virus-specific immunity. In addition to IFN-
, NK cells have been documented to secrete TNF-
, GM-CSF, IL-5, IL-13, IL-10, TGF-β, MIP-1
, MIP-1β, RANTES, NO, etc. (reviewed in ref. [14
]). In addition to their immunoregulatory properties, IFN-
and TNF-
can induce an antiviral state in the host cells and inhibit virus replication by noncytopathic mechanisms. This virtual curing of the infected cells is increasingly being appreciated in controlling viral infections [15
]. |
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 3. NK Cell Functions
|
NK cell–DC interactions are complex and are important for innate and adaptive immune responses against viral infections. They will be discussed in a later section in this article.
NK cell interactions with other immune cells are important for the induction of effective immune responses. It has been shown that NK cells can regulate adaptive CD4+ memory T cells. More specifically, adoptive transfer of CD4+ memory T cells specific for myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG; an autoantigen) is able to expand and cause experimental autoimmune encephalitis (EAE; a mouse model of multiple sclerosis) in RAG-2-deficient mice, which lack T and B cells but have functional NK cells. However, NK cells in these mice are inhibited from killing the CD4+ memory T cells, as the latter expresses Qa-1 (the mouse equivalent of human HLA-E). The transferred cells do not cause EAE in Qa-1 lacking mice. NK cells kill MOG-specific CD4+ memory T cells in these mice. These results show that NK cells play an important role in the homeostasis of memory T cells and may also eliminate autoreactive CD4+ memory T cells under appropriate conditions. The results suggest that blocking Qa-1/NKG2A interactions may represent a better clinical strategy to eliminate autoreactive T cells than using anti-CD3 antibodies [25 ].
In certain mouse models, NK cell activation has been shown to be indispensable for inducing antitumor antibody and CTL responses [17
, 26
]. In addition to producing IFN-
, physical interactions between NK cells and other immunocytes are needed for these responses. For example, via CD40/CD40L interactions, NK cells can induce transcription of activation-induced cytidine deaminase and switch recombinations in B cells [27
].
NK cells are plastic and may differentiate themselves into cell types that produce predominantly IFN-
or IL-5. It is not known what causes this polarization in NK cells. It has also been suggested that these differences in cytokine production may result from their different differentiation states. Nevertheless, this polarized production of cytokines from NK cells may be correlated with certain disease conditions. For example, IL-5- and IFN-
-producing NK cells were shown to correlate with remissions and relapses in multiple sclerosis in humans, respectively [28
]. The NK cells producing predominantly IL-5 also expand and play a role in asthma in humans [29
].
In a provocative study, NK cells were shown to mediate memory-type responses. In RAG–/– mice, which lack T and B cells, O'Leary et al. [30 ] demonstrated NK cell-dependent, anamnestic responses to a hapten in mediating contact hypersensitivity. Although the molecular mechanisms behind this NK cell-dependent memory are not clear, the results may have important implications for development of vaccines.
NK cells play an important role in successful pregnancy and reproductive efficiency. The KIR2DL4/HLA-G interactions and consequent secretion of IFN-
from uterine NK cells are needed for placentation [31
, 32
].
/β, IL-2, IL-12, IL-15, IL-18, IL-21, and others [14
, 33
]. Of these cytokines, IL-15, IL-21, and fms-like tyrosine kinase 3 ligand have been found to be essential for the development, differentiation, and homeostasis of NK cells. IL-15 knockout (KO) mice are deficient in NK cells. Furthermore, NK cells from normal mice undergo apoptosis when transfused into IL-15 KO mice (reviewed in ref. [34
]). |
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 4. How NK Cells Become Activated in Viral Infections
|
NK cells mainly kill their target cells by releasing cytotoxic molecules (perforin, granzymes, and granulysin), which are normally contained in their granules. These molecules are released within the immune synapse (IS) onto the surface of the target cells. NK cells can also kill target cells by FasL, TRAIL, and TNF-
if the target cells express appropriate receptors [41
, 42
]. NK-cell mediated lysis is usually determined in microcytotoxicity assays by measuring the release of 51chromium, lactate dehydrogenase, or perforin in culture supernatants. Individual NK cells mediating the lysis can be recognized and counted by detecting the expression of lysosomal protein lysosome-associated membrane protein-1 (CD107a) on their surface [43
, 44
].
). A ring of F actin surrounds the center of the synapse and prevents spillover of the cytotoxic mediators from the synapse. Within the synapse, NK and target cells interact with each other via membranous protrusions, which end at coated pits on the surface of opposing cells [46
]. The Src homology 2 (SH2) domain-containing phosphatase (SHP)-1 is recruited to the periphery of the synapse within 1 min. It limits the activation event to the center of the synapse. Actin polymerization and MTOC reorganization are key events needed to trigger NK cell cytotoxicity (degranulation). The pharmacological agents that inhibit actin polymerization also inhibit NK cell-mediated killing [47
]. Another phosphatase, SHIP, is also recruited to the synapse within minutes to terminate the triggering of the NK cell. After discharging its cytotoxic mediators to the membrane of the target cell, the NK cell separates itself and is ready to kill another target cell. A single NK cell can kill several target cells in a sequence one after the other. The inhibitory IS is formed between an NK cell and a resistant target cell. Its formation is prevented at an early stage by inhibitory receptor-recruited phosphatases. The inhibitory receptors cluster in discrete microdomains in the center of the inhibitory synapse and interact with their cognate ligands.
![]() View larger version (64K): [in a new window] |
Figure 1. Formation of IS between NK and target cells. Various NKRs interact with their cognate ligands on the target cell in the center of the synapse, which contains lipid rafts and activating NKRs. The adhesion molecules [CD2, LFA-1, membrane-activated complex 1 (MAC-1)] bind to their cognate ligands on the target cell and aggregate in the form of a ring. Activation of integrins leads to talin-mediated actin polymerization. The close contact between NK and target cell membranes induces reorientation of the microtubule-organizing center (MTOC) of the NK cell toward the synapse. The microtubule-associated motor proteins (kinesins) shuttle granules containing cytotoxic mediators toward the center of the synapse. Within the center of the synapse, different activating NKRs interact with their cognate ligands on the target cells. A ring of F actin surrounds the center of the synapse, preventing the spillover of the cytotoxic mediators from the synapse. T and NK indicate target cell and NK cell, respectively. C and P represent center and periphery of the synapse. WASP, Wiskott-Aldrich syndrome protein; PTK, protein tyrosine kinase; SYK, spleen tyrosine kinase; SRC, sarcoma tyrosine kinase.
|
NK cells, like other immune cells, can also communicate with other cells at a distance by forming nanotubules and transfer molecules and Ca++ fluxes to them (reviewed in ref. [50 ]).
![]() View larger version (70K): [in a new window] |
Figure 2. Model for NK cell-mediated killing of virus-infected cells. Normal cells express ligands (usually MHC class I molecules) for inhibitory receptors of NK cells and are resistant to NK cell-mediated killing (top panel). Viral infections may reduce the expression of these inhibitory ligands on the infected cells and make them susceptible to killing by NK cells (middle panel). They may further induce expression of ligands for activating NKRs (e.g., for NKG2D) and make them super-susceptible to the killing (bottom panel).
|
KIR (CD158) family
The KIR are type I integral membrane glycoproteins that are usually expressed as monomers on the cell surface [51
52
53
]. At present, 14 distinct KIR genes and two pseudogenes have been described (see http://www.ebi.ac.uk/ipd/kir for an update on KIR genes and alleles). They are located on human chromosome 19q13.4 in a tandem head-to-tail manner in a short, 150-kb region, called leukocyte receptor complex (LRC). KIR genes show extensive allelic polymorphism. For example, KIR2DL1 and KIR3DL1 genes have at least 14 and 47 alleles, respectively. Their transcripts also undergo alternate splicing, giving rise to distinct receptor variants. It has been estimated that after MHC, KIR is the most polymorphic locus in humans. KIR genes are not present in mice, suggesting their recent evolution after divergence of the two species 5 million years ago. They are undergoing rapid evolution in humans under pressure from pathogens, malignancy, and autoimmunity. Two human populations living next to each other and having similar HLA genes frequently differ with respect to their KIR genes. This observation suggests that the latter genes are evolving faster than the former ones.
KIR structure.
A typical KIR gene contains nine exons as illustrated in Figure 3
. The exons encode leader sequence (exons 1 and 2), extracellular Ig-like domains (D0, D1, and D2; exons 3–5), stem (exon 6), transmembrane region (exon 7), and cytoplasmic tail (exons 8 and 9) of the KIR. The two-domain KIR lack an extracellular domain (D0 or D1). The ones lacking D0 (KIR2L1, KIR2DL2/3) are called type I KIR, whereas the ones lacking D1 (KIR2DL4 and KIR2DL5; see below) are called type II KIR. The structure of a typical KIR gene along with the receptor is shown in Figure 3
. The extracellular region of the receptor binds with its ligand and consists of two or three Ig-like domains. The cytoplasmic tail transduces receptor-initiated signals. Depending on the length of the cytoplasmic tail, a KIR could be short-tailed (S) or long-tailed (L). The L forms are usually inhibitory KIR and have two ITIMs (with canonical sequence I/VxYxxL) in their cytoplasmic tails, as depicted in Figure 4
. Upon binding to their ligands, the tyrosine residues in the ITIMs become phosphorylated and recruit SHP-1 and -2. These phosphatases dephosphorylate several substrates involved in the NK cell activation cascade, e.g., Vav,
-associated protein 70 (Zap-70), Syk, phospholipase C (PLC)-
1, Shc, and SH2 domain-containing leukocyte protein of 76 kDa, and inhibit the NK cell from triggering its cytotylic machinery and secreting cytokines. The receptors with a short (S) cytoplasmic tail are stimulatory. They lack ITIMs but possess a positively charged amino acid (lysine) in their transmembrane regions. Via this amino acid, they associate noncovalently with a dimer of an adaptor protein, killer cell-activating receptor-associated protein (KARAP) or DAP-12 [54
]. Each DAP-12 carries ITAMs [with canonical sequence D/Ex(0–2)YxxL/Ix(6–8)YxxL/I] in its cytoplasmic tail. When an activating KIR binds to its ligand, the tyrosine residues in the ITAMs are phosphorylated and recruit various tyrosine kinases, e.g., Syk and Zap-70, and send activating signals to NK cells to kill target cells and secrete cytokines. The signals converge to phosphorylate Vav, which is a guanine nucleotide exchange factor (GEF) and activates the Rho family of small GTPases. Upon activation, the GTPases cause actin polymerization, cytoskeleton rearrangement, and triggerring of degranulation (reviewed in ref. [45
]).
![]() View larger version (42K): [in a new window] |
Figure 3. Structure of a typical KIR gene and its encoded receptor. A typical KIR gene comprises nine exons shown here on the right side of the figure. Double horizontal lines in the gene indicate introns. The schematic structure of the encoded receptor is shown on the left. The part of the receptor encoded by each individual exon is also indicated. The scissor in the figure indicates cleavage site for the signal peptide. The letters N and C designate N- and C-terminals of the protein, respectively; not drawn to the scale. D0, -1, -2, Extracellular Ig-like domains; TM, transmembrane region.
|
![]() View larger version (45K): [in a new window] |
Figure 4. MHC-binding NKRs. The figure shows the schematic structures of main MHC-binding receptors: KIR, ILT-2, and CD94/NKG2. The ligands for the receptors are also shown on the top of each receptor; not drawn to the scale. DAP-12, Dynax activation protein 12.
|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 5. Human KIR (CD158) and Their Ligands
|
-2 helices: They have asparagine or lysine. The HLA-C with an asparagine at p80 (e.g., HLA-Cw2, -4, -5, -6, -17, and -18) are called group I HLA-C, whereas the ones with a lysine at p80 (e.g., HLA-Cw1, -3, -7, -8, -13, and -14) are called group II HLA-C. The KIR2DL1 binds group II HLA-C, and KIR2DL2 and its allelic variant (KIR2DL3) bind group I HLA-C [53
, 55
56
57
58
] (reviewed in refs. [53
, 54
]). Thus, each HLA-C allotype is recognized by KIR2DL1 or by KIR2DL2/3. Interestingly, the amino acid at p44 of the protein sequence of a KIR determines its specificity for a given HLA-C group: If it is methionine (as in the case of KIR2DL1), the KIR binds group II HLA-C, and if it is lysine (as in the case of KIR2DL2/3), the KIR binds group I HLA-C [56
]. It may be relevant to mention here that these ligand specificities are not absolute: KIR2DL1 and KR2DL2/3 may bind to group I and group II HLA-C ligands, respectively. However, they do so with tenfold lower affinities.
KIR2DL4 (CD158d) is unusual in several respects. First, it binds HLA-G: a nonclassical HLA antigen. Second, it is expressed mainly in endocytic vesicles and binds internalized, soluble HLA-G. Third, the receptor is expressed usually by all human NK cells. Its expression can also be increased by cytokines, e.g., IL-2. Fourthly, the receptor has an ITIM-containing, long cytoplasmic tail (a typical feature of an inhibitory KIR) as well as a charged amino acid (arginine) in its transmembrane region (a feature of an activating KIR). The presence of a charged amino acid in its transmembrane region allows it to associate noncovalently with the signaling adaptor molecule
chain of the Fc
RI. Cross-linking of the receptor with HLA-G-expressing target cells induces secretion of IFN-
from NK cells but does not trigger cytotoxicity [59
60
61
62
63
64
]. It is noteworthy that HLA-G is expressed in the female reproductive tract, invading placental trophoblasts and thymic epithelial cells. The HLA-G/KIR2DL4 interactions may be important in generating local immune responses against invading pathogens in the female reproductive tract. Uterine NK cells express KIR2DL4, and secretion of IFN-
from uterine NK cells has been shown to be crucial for vascularization of placenta (reviewed in ref. [65
]). KIR2DL4 is expressed at lower levels on uterine NK cells in women undergoing spontaneous, recurrent abortions [32
]. Gomez-Lozano et al. [66
] have described a multiparous woman lacking KIR2DL4 in her genome. It is probable that a KIR2DL4-like receptor may have compensated the function of this receptor in this woman.
The KIR2DL5A and KIR2DL5B were considered as allelic forms of the same gene. However, now, it has become quite obvious that they represent two closely related but distinct genes, which are present in telomeric and centromeric halves of the KIR gene cluster, respectively [67 ]. The KIR haplotypes may have both, none, or one of the two genes. In fact, the KIR genes are evolving so rapidly that our conventional ways of distinguishing between alleles and genes are being challenged. KIR2DL5A (previously known as KIR2DL5*001 allele) is expressed, like other clonally expressed KIR genes, as a monomer on CD56low NK cells in a variegated manner. It is also expressed on a subset of T cells [68 ]. Individuals (52–80%) may express this receptor, depending on the population group. KIR2DL5B is a hybrid gene that arose from recombination between KIR2DL5A and KIR3DP1 genes. It has three alleles, KIR2DL5B*002, *003, and *004, of which only *003 is expressed. The KIR2DL5 A and B genes have 99.58% sequence similarity in their exons. Each KI2DL5 receptor has two ITIMs, of which one is atypical. The receptor has inhibitory function and preferentially recruits SHP-2 [69 ]. The ligand for KIR2DL5 is not known. However, their extracellular regions are similar to that of KIR2DL4. Therefore, it is believed that KIR2DL5 receptors also bind HLA-G. Interestingly, KIR2DL5 genes are conserved among primates.
Three-domain KIR and their ligands.
Of the three-domain KIR, KIR3DL1 (p70) is expressed as a monomer on the surface of NK cells. It binds to HLA-B and HLA-A allotypes bearing the HLA-Bw4 serospecificity. It is noteworthy that all HLA-B allotypes can be divided into two mutually exclusive Bw4 or Bw6 serospecificities depending on residues 77–83. About one-third of all HLA-B and some HLA-A allotypes are Bw4+. The remaining two-thirds of the HLA-B allotypes is Bw6+. It may be relevant to mention here that HLA-Bw4 allotypes also show dimorphism at p80 of their amino-acid sequence: They may have isoleucine (HLA-Bw4-I) or threonine (HLA-Bw4-T) at this position. It was demonstrated that KIR3DL1 receptors bind the former HLA-Bw4 allotypes with higher affinity [70
, 71
]. As mentioned above, the KIR3DL1 gene exists in 47 allelic forms, encoding 41 distinct allotypes, which differ in their ability to bind their MHC ligands. Interestingly, this binding is dependent on the peptide bound to the peptide-binding groove of the MHC class I ligand [72
73
74
]. Some KIR3DL1 allotypes (*001, *002, *008, *015, *009) are expressed at relatively higher levels on the surface of NK cells, and others (*005, *007) are expressed at lower levels. Epidemiological data from Martin et al. [75
] suggest that the highly expressed KIR3DL1 allotypes bind HLA-Bw4-I allotypes with high affinity, as their coinheritance gives the highest protection from AIDS in HIV-infected individuals. Furthermore, it also suggests that the lowly expressed KIR3DL1 allotypes bind with HLA-Bw4-T allotypes better than with HLA-Bw4-I ones. This assumption explains the better protection provided by these KIR allotypes, when they are coinherited with HLA-Bw-T as compared with HLA-Bw4-I allotypes. However, these findings need to be tested by direct-binding assays. One KIR3DL1 allotype (*004) is not expressed on the cell surface and remains intracellular. Still, it appears to be of some functional significance [74
75
76
].
Although KIR3DS1 encodes an activating KIR, it segregates as an allelic variant of KIR3DL1. To date, 12 allelic variants have been described, which encode 10 distinct allotypes of KIR3DS1. It is noteworthy that KIR3DS1 and KIR3DL1 show more than 95% sequence homology in their extracellular domains. Genetic epidemiological data strongly suggest HLA-Bw4-I allotypes as ligands for KIR3DS1 [77 ]. Nevertheless, KIR3DS1 failed to bind HLA-Bw4 tetramers as well as HLA-Bw4 ligands when expressed in EBV-transformed human cells [78 ]. It is likely that the receptor binds to HLA-Bw4 ligands when the latter has bound a certain foreign peptide.
KIR3DL2 (NKAT4; p140) is expressed as homodimers on the surface of NK cells. It binds different HLA-A antigens when complexed with certain peptides derived from the viral protein EBV nuclear antigen 1 (reviewed in ref. [53 ]). The ligands for other KIR are not yet known (see Table 5 ).
Affinities of KIR for their ligands.
It is important to note that KIR differ in their affinities for their MHC ligands. For example, the KIR2DL1 binds with group II HLA-C with higher affinities than does KIR2DL2 for its respective MHC ligands (group I HLA-C). Furthermore, KIR2DL2 has higher affinity for its ligands than its allelic variant KIR2DL3. Similarly different KIR3DL1 allotypes bind to HLA-Bw4 allotypes with different affinities. These differences in affinities of different KIR for their respective MHC ligands are important from the functional point of view as they translate into different levels of inhibition of the NK cells. The differences in affinities are more pronounced between activating and inhibitory KIR.
The S KIR have activating functions. They may represent an allelic variant of an inhibitory KIR gene (e.g., KIR3DS1 is an allelic form of the KIR3DL1) or may represent a distinct activating KIR gene (e.g., KIR2DS4). It is believed that activating KIR bind the same HLA antigens as do their inhibitory counterparts but with several orders of magnitude lower affinities. In fact, many authors believe that these receptors may bind some unknown ligands expressed by human pathogens, malignant cells, and/or they may bind their cognate MHC ligands that have bound foreign pathogen-derived peptides [52 , 53 , 79 ]. It is noteworthy that KIR2DS4 was reported to bind an unknown ligand present on the surface of melanoma cells [80 ]. The idea is supported further by the fact that certain activating forms of LY49, which are functional homologues of KIR expressed on murine NK cells, bind certain viral proteins. For example, an activating receptor LY49H, which is present on NK cells in C57BL/6 mice, binds a murine CMV (MCMV)-encoded glycoprotein m157 and protects the host from the virus [81 ]. The virus-susceptible mouse strain 129/SvJ lacks this receptor and instead expresses an inhibitory receptor LY49I for the viral glycoprotein on NK cells. The viral glycoprotein m157 is an MHC class I homologue encoded by MCMV to evade the hosts NK cell responses [1 ]. Another activating receptor LY49P recognizes MHC class I antigens (H-2DK) in mice when bound with a viral peptide [82 ].
A functional consequence of the different affinities of the inhibitory and activating KIR for their MHC ligands is that under physiological conditions, inhibitory KIR act as dominant-negative regulators for NK cell functions. They are the main receptors that regulate NK cell functions in humans and maintain tolerance of NK cells toward ones own cells.
KIR-binding and MHC-bound peptides.
The binding of two-domain KIR to their MHC ligands is sensitive to the nature of the bound peptide. Certain amino-acid side-chains at p7 and p8 of the peptide may interfere with the binding [83
]. Otherwise, these KIR do not distinguish between self and nonself peptides bound to their MHC ligands. However, the three-domain KIR are sensitive to the peptide bound to Bw4. Usually, they can bind to their MHC class I ligands complexed with endogenous peptides. This prevents NK cells from killing the bodys own cells. The binding of a foreign peptide to their MHC ligands may abrogate their binding with these KIR. This may result in loss of the KIR-imposed inhibition on the NK cell. For example, the binding of a neomycin-derived peptide to HLA-B27 abrogates its recognition by KIR3DL1 [84
]. Neomycin-expressing cells are no longer recognized by NK cells expressing this KIR and hence, may be killed. Such interference with KIR recognition may have consequences for the cells susceptibility to NK cell-mediated killing. In this respect, the three-domain KIR behave as TCRs as far as recognition of HLA molecules is concerned. However, the consequences of the recognition are quite opposite to each other: T cells recognize HLA via TCR and kill target cells, whereas NK cells recognize HLA via KIR3DL1 and spare them from killing. As three-domain KIR may recognize several HLA ligands in association with one or more pathogen-derived peptides, they essentially remain pattern-recognizing molecules, and TCRs recognize only a particular HLA in association with a well-defined, single foreign peptide and are antigen-specific.
CD94/NKG2C killer lectin-like receptor (KLR)-C (NKG2/CD94 family)
They are also known as the NKG2/CD94 family of receptors. The receptors of this family are type II, C-type, lectin-like integral membrane glycoproteins. As shown in Figure 4
, they are expressed on the cell surface as heterodimers with CD94 (NKp43; KLR-D1), which is also a type II, C-type, lectin-like polypeptide. CD94 lacks a cytoplasmic tail and cannot transduce signals. However, it is essential for the cell surface expression of NKG2 receptors. Members of this family as well as other non-KIR human NKR are given in Table 6
. There are four receptors in the family: A/B (KLR-C1), C (KLR-C2), E/H (KLR-C3), and F (KLR-C4). B and H represent splice variants of A and E genes, respectively [52
, 54
, 85
]. The genes for these receptors are located on human chromosome 12p12.3–p13.2 in a region called NK gene complex (NGC). Of these receptors, CD94/NKG2A has inhibitory function, and it carries two ITIMs in its long cytoplasmic tail. It is expressed in a subset of human NK cells having the CD56high CD16low phenotype. It is also expressed, albeit at lower levels, on the CD56low subset of NK cells. NKG2C has a short cytoplasmic tail, associates noncovalently with a homodimer of DAP-12, and activates NK cells upon binding with its ligands. NKG2E is also considered an activating receptor. It has a charged amino acid (lysine) in its transmembrane region, but it does not associate with DAP-12. The NKG2A and NKG2C are expressed on overlapping subsets of CD56+ NK cells [54
]. NKG2F has a truncated extracellular domain comprising only 12 amino acids. It has a charged amino acid (lysine) in the transmembrane region and two ITIMs in its cytoplasmic tail. The protein is retained intracellularly. It does not form heterodimers with CD94 but can complex with DAP-12 [86
]. Thus, it may sequester DAP-12 and regulate functional activities of other receptors that use DAP-12 as a signaling partner. Interestingly, DAP-12 has also been implicated in myelination and bone resorption (reviewed in ref. [87
]).
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 6. Non-KIR NKRs
|
, TNF-
, and IL-1β [94
]. The expression of HLA-E on human cells may protect them from NKG2A-bearing NK cells, and soluble HLA-E may interfere with this protection. The KLR family NKRs have nonclassical, lectin-like domains. Therefore, they can bind nonsugar moieties on their ligands [95 ] (reviewed in ref. [96 ]). It has been demonstrated in vitro that NKG2A can bind efficiently to HLA-E produced in bacteria.
ILT (CD85) family
The family has also been given other names: leukocyte Ig-like receptor (LILR) and macrophage Ig-like receptors. It comprises 13 members. They vary in the number of Ig-like domains present in their extracellular regions and may be inhibitory or activating as in the case of KIR (reviewed in refs. [52
, 54
]). They are mostly expressed on monocytes, macrophages, DC, and certain subsets of B and T cells. One member of the family ILT-2 (LILRB1; CD85j) is also expressed on a subset of NK cells (Fig. 5
and Table 6
). The receptor has four Ig-like domains in its extracellular region and four ITIMs in its cytoplasmic tail. ILTs bind classical and nonclassical HLA molecules (e.g., HLA-G). ILT-2 preferentially binds HLA-G [97
]. It interacts with the
3 domain of the MHC class I molecules and competes with CD8 for binding to the MHC ligand [98
]. ILT genes are present on chromosome 19 close to the KIR gene cluster.
![]() View larger version (44K): [in a new window] |
Figure 5. Non-MHC-binding NKRs. The receptors, their ligands, and signaling partners are shown. ITSM, Immunoreceptor tyrosine-based switch motif; Col, collagens. The YxxM motif, when phosphorylated, recruits PI-3K; not drawn to the scale. The question mark (?) indicates that the ligand is unknown. NTB-A, NK-T-B (NK, T-B cell antigen) antigen; LAIR-1, leukocyte-associated Ig-like receptors.
|

TCR-positive T cells, and a subset of CD8+ T lymphocytes. It binds HLA-C, -G and other HLA molecules. NK cell stimulation via CD160 leads to secretion of a unique, proinflammatory profile of cytokines: IFN-
, TNF-
, and IL-6. A soluble form of the molecule, shed from activated human NK cells, can inhibit functions of CD160+ NK and T cells [99
]. CD160-positive NK and CTL are usually implicated in inflammatory conditions.
Non-MHC-binding receptors
NK cells also express several types of receptors, which recognize different molecular structures (but not MHC antigens) present on the surface of target cells. These receptors are as below.
NKG2D receptor (KLR-K1; CD314)
Originally, this receptor was placed in the CD94/NKG2 family. However, it differs from members of this family in many respects. It does not form heterodimers with CD94 (see Fig. 5
and Table 6
). It is expressed as homodimers, and each homodimer associates noncovalently with a homodimer of an adaptor protein DAP-10, which is a DAP-12-related protein but does not contain ITAM motifs in its cytoplasmic tails [100
]. Instead, DAP-10 carries a YxxM motif, which upon phosphorylation of its tyrosine residues, can recruit the regulatory subunit p85 of PI-3K and growth-factor receptor-bound protein 2. This motif is also present in the cytoplasmic tail of the T cell costimulatory molecule CD28. However, there are important differences between CD28- and NKG2D-transduced signals. The engagement of NKG2D alone, but not of CD28, on NK as well as on T cells allows formation of an IS with target cells [101
].
The NKG2D receptors do not recognize and bind HLA-E, as do all members of the CD94/NKG2 family. Instead, they bind MICA, MICB, and the HCMV ULBPs [102
]. MIC genes are located on human chromosome 6q25 outside the MHC locus. Of the six distinct MIC genes, only MICA and MICB are transcribed. Structurally, MIC proteins resemble MHC class I heavy chain, and each has three (
1,
2, and
3) domains; however, they do not bind antigenic peptides and do not complex with β-2 microglobulin. The MIC genes are highly polymorphic. At least 54 MICA and 19 MICB alleles have been described. The MIC allotypes vary in their ability to bind NKG2D (reviewed in ref. [103
]). For example, MICA*01 and 07 allotypes bind strongly, and MICA*016 binds NKG2D weakly. Some allotypes such as MICA*08 and *010 are defective and are not expressed on the cell surface. Thus, an individuals capacity to mediate NKG2D-mediated killing may depend on his/her inherited MIC genes. Under physiological conditions, the expression of MICA and MICB is restricted to the basolateral surface of intestinal epithelial cells and fibroblasts. However, they can be induced de novo on different host cells by stress, transformation, and viral infections. More specifically, DNA damage response triggered by stalled DNA replication, genotoxic drugs, irradiation, and hydroxyurea induces expression of MIC and other NKG2D ligands. The response is accompanied by activation of ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) and ATM and Rad-3-related (ATR) kinases. The stimuli, which do not result in the induction of DNA damage response and activation of ATM and ATR (e.g., heat shock, hypoxia, inflammation, TNF-
, or IL-8), do not induce expression of NKG2D ligands [104
105
106
107
]. MIC proteins may be cleaved via matrix metalloproteinases and shed from the cell surface as soluble proteins, which bind to and down-regulate the expression of NKG2D on NK cells. Tumor cells usually shed these proteins as an immune evasion mechanism [108
, 109
].
The ULBPs were first discovered by their ability to bind UL-16 of HCMV and appear to have ubiquitous expression at the mRNA level. Five distinct ULBPs (1–5) have been identified. Of these, ULBP3 and -4 do not bind UL16. Structurally, they resemble MIC proteins but lack
-3 domains and could be GPI-anchored (ULBP1, -2, and -3) or have transmembrane regions (ULBP4 and -5; reviewed in refs. [110
, 111
]). In the mouse, NKG2D recognizes H-60 (a minor histocompatibility antigen), the retinoic acid early inducible protein 1 (Rae-1), and a murine ULBP-like transcript 1 (reviewed in ref. [96
]).
NKG2D is an activating NKR. In addition to NK cells, resting and activated human CD8+ T lymphocytes express NKG2D [112
]. Both of these cell types can efficiently kill NKG2D ligand-positive target cells. The CD8+ T cells do so without their TCR coengagement [113
]. Certain cytokines, e.g., IL-12 and IL-15, can increase expression of NKG2D on these cytotoxic cells, whereas cytokines such as TGF-β and IL-10 can decrease their expression. The cytokine-induced, increased expression of NKG2D on CTL greatly enhances their NK cell-like killing capabilities (reviewed in ref. [111
]). NK cells may play an anti-inflammatory role by killing overtly activated macrophages, which start expressing ligands for NKG2D [17
]. It is noteworthy that stimulation of macrophages via TLR induces NKG2DL in macrophages [114
]. On the other hand, certain cytokines such as IL-1β and TNF-
have been shown to induce MIC and ULBP expression on oligodendrocytes and neurons. NKG2D-mediated killing of oligodendrocytes has been shown to play a role in the development of multiple sclerosis in humans [115
].
Natural cytotoxicity receptors (NCRs)
Three NKRs, NKp46 (CD335), NKp30 (CD337), and NKp44, are called NCRs (Table 6
and Fig. 5
). They trigger NK cell-mediated killing and secretion of IFN-
upon their engagement. NKp46 and NKp30 are expressed on resting and activated NK cells, whereas NKp44 is expressed only on cytokine-activated NK cells [116
117
118
]. NCRs belong to the Ig superfamily (IgSF). They have extracellular Ig domains and associate noncovalently with DAP-12 (NKp44),
-
(NKp46), and
-
chains (NKp30). The ligands for the NCR mostly remain unknown. Two members of the group, NKp46 and NKp44, are known to bind the sialic acid-binding glycoproteins, e.g., HA and HA-neuraminidase, of the influenza and parainfluenza viruses, respectively [40
].
2,6-Linked sialic acid moieties and the sugar-carrying residue Thr 225 near the membrane proximal region of the receptor play an important role in binding to the ligands [119
]. The NCR ligands may also occur on normal hematopoietic cells. For example, NK cells specifically use NKp30 to kill immature DC, suggesting that these cells bear NKp30 ligands. NKp46-positive NK cells protect host from influenza viruses, as the viruses cause lethal infections in NKp46-deficient mice [120
].
NKR-P1 (CD161; KLR-B1)
The receptors occur as s–s-bonded homodimers on the cell surface. They were first described in mice as NKR-P1C or NK1.1 antigen occurring on NK cells of C57BL/6 mice. In rodents, five distinct genes (A, B, C, D, and F) have been described. They encode activating receptors except for B and D genes, which encode inhibitory versions of the receptor. The humans have A gene. Its protein (CD161) is expressed on NK cells, NKT cells, and a fraction of CD8+ T cells. The human CD161 binds LLT-1 and transmits activating signals via the
-chain of the Fc
RI. LLT-1 is usually expressed on monocytes and T, B, and NK cells. IL-2 can induce its expression on NK cells. The receptor differentially regulates NK and T cell functions: It increases TCR-mediated IFN-
production in T cells but inhibits cytotoxicity and IFN-
production in NK cells [121
]. Another study has shown that the receptor cross-linking induces IFN-
production but not cytotoxicity in human NK cells [122
]. Thus, the receptor may perform dual functions. The occurrence of the receptor and its ligand on NK and T cells suggests that the receptor may interact with its ligand in cis.
SLAM-related receptors (SRRs)
The SLAM (CD150) is expressed in T cells and transmits its signals via an adaptor protein called SLAM-associated protein (SAP; or SH2D1A). The SRRs include 2B4 (CD244), NTB-A (Ly108), and CD2-like receptor on activated cytoxic cells (CRACC; CD139). These receptors are related to SLAM, as they all use similar signaling molecules, SAP, or related molecules (see Table 6
). The genes for SRR are located on human chromosome1q22. They are expressed on NK cells, monocytes, basophils, 
TCR-bearing T cells, and CD8+ T cells of the effector/memory phenotype (Fig. 5)
. The receptors bear so-called ITSM (TIYxxV/I) in their cytoplasmic tails. These receptors transmit activating signals via SAP, which has a motif in its SH2 domain centered on Arg 78. This motif binds the SH3 domain of the src family kinase Fyn (reviewed in ref. [123
]). SAP-Fyn-mediated signaling is important for TH2-type cytokine responses. Interestingly, SAP KO mice lack NKT cells [124
]. A distal tyrosine-based motif (TVYxxV/I) in the cytoplasmic tail of the receptor can recruit SHIP, which can dephosphorylate phosphatidyl 3,4,5-triphosphate to phosphatidyl 3,4-biphosphate. Another SAP-like adaptor protein, EAT-2 or SH2D1B, can replace SAP and associates with SRRs. However, EAT-2 cannot recruit Fyn. In the absence of SAP, 2B4 may act as an inhibitory receptor. As a result of this ability of 2B4 to act as an inhibitory as well as an activating receptor, it is recognized as a receptor with dual functionality. Early in ontogeny when NK cells become cytolytic but still have not yet expressed KIR and NKG2A receptors, they do not express SAP. 2B4 acts as an inhibitory receptor and prevents autoaggression from these developing NK cells. It has been demonstrated that EAT-2 and SAP bind 2B4 in resting and activated NK cells, respectively. The ligand for 2B4 is CD48, which is widely expressed on human cells except plasmacytoid DC. Interestingly, 2B4 in mice mainly acts as an inhibitory receptor. 2B4 KO mice show increased cytotoxicity against CD48-expressing target cells. The mouse NK cells also express a EAT-2-related transducer, which like EAT-2, cannot recruit Fyn. The gene for SAP is located on the X chromosome in humans. It is noteworthy that genetic defects in SAP can cause X-linked lymphoproliferative disease and fatal EBV infections in humans [125
, 126
]. NTB-A, like 2B4, may bind SAP and EAT-2. The two adapters seem to control cytokine production and cytotoxicity in NK cells, respectively [127
]. In resting NK cells, CRACC binds EAT-2 but dissociates from it upon activation and recruits PI-3K and PLC-
. NK cells may interact with macrophages, CTL, and other cells via 2B4/CD48 interactions.
KLR-G1 or mast cell function-associated antigen
It is a type II lectin-like inhibitory receptor expressed as an s–s-bonded dimer on the surface of mast cells. It is also expressed on antigen-specific CTL of the effector/memory phenotype, a subset of CD56dim NK cells, and certain CD4+ T cells in humans as well as in mice [128
]. Its cross-linking inhibits cytokine secretion and cytotoxicity but not proliferation. It inhibits IgE-mediated activation of mast cells. The receptors bind ubiquitously expressed endothelial (E), neural, and retinal cadherins or junction proteins [129
]. Interestingly, E-cadherins are lost in epithelial tumors undergoing metastasis.
FcRL
They make a growing family of molecules with homology to Fc
RI. All FcRL are mainly expressed on B cells; however, one member of the family, FcRL6, is expressed on the surface of NK cells as well as on a subset of CD8+ T cells of the effector-memory phenotypes [130
]. Its novel cytoplasmic, cysteine-rich motif can recruit SHP-2 and inhibit cellular functions.
NKp80 (KLR-F1)
It is a type II lectin-like molecule expressed as s–s-bonded homodimers on the surface of NK and CD3+CD56+ T cells. The cytoplasmic tail has two E/KxYxxL/T tyrosine-based motifs. It is expressed on NCRdull and NCRbright NK cells. The receptor binds AICL, which is a myeloid-specific activating receptor [131
]. Its gene is located in the NGC close to that of CD69.
DNAM-1 (CD226)
The receptor belongs to the IgSF. It is expressed on the surface of NK, T, and a subset of B cells in physical association with LFA-1. Its gene is located on human chromosome 18q22.3 (Fig. 5)
. Its ligands include PVR (CD155), Nectin-2 (CD112), and nectin-like molecules, which are widely expressed on a variety of cells, e.g., endothelial, epithelial, and neuronal cells and fibroblasts [113
]. The receptor is implicated in transendothelial migration, diapedesis, costimulation, and adhesion. A receptor closely related to DNAM-1 is CD96 (TACTILE). It bears 20% homology with DNAM-1 and also binds to nectins and nectin-like molecules.
Four Ig-like B7 homologues (4IgB7H or B7H)
These receptors belong to the B7 family and are expressed on NK and T cells. They may activate or inhibit the cell. One member of the family, B7-H1 [also called programmed death (PD) ligand-1], is expressed on NK cells. Its expression is increased by certain chemokines (e.g., CXCL-9, -10, and -11) on NK cells [132
]. The receptor is also expressed and/or can be induced on several cell types in the body. The receptor interacts with its ligand PD-1 and causes premature activation of naïve T cells and inhibition/apoptosis of antigen-specific effector cells. It may be relevant to mention here that increased expression of PD-1 on HIV-specific T cells has been implicated in immunodeficiency in HIV-infected persons [133
].
SIGLEC-7 [p75; adhesion receptor molecule-1; (AIRM-1); CD328]
SIGLECs are a family of sialic acid-binding Ig-like lectins, which belong to the superfamily of sialoadhesion proteins. Of these molecules, SIGLEC-7 (or AIRM-1) is expressed on the surface of human NK cells. Two other molecules, SIGLEC-9 (CD329) and SIGLEC-3 (CD33), are expressed relatively weakly on human NK cells. The SIGLECs transduce inhibitory signals upon binding with sialic acid moieties.
CEACAM-1 (CD66a)
It binds CEA and CEA-related antigens, which are expressed on tumor cells. The binding inhibits NK cell-mediated functions [134
]. One of its ligands is PECAM-1 (CD31), which is expressed on vacscular endothelial cells as well as on NK cells. Cross-linking CD31 on NK cells activates LFA-1 [135
].
LAIR
Two members of the family, LAIR-1 (CD305) and LAIR–2 (CD306), have been described [52
, 54
]. They are ubiquitously expressed on all leukocytes including NK cells. LAIR-1 has one Ig-like domain in its extracellular region and one ITIM in its cytoplasmic tail. The receptors bind collagens, which are abundantly expressed proteins in the body. Collagens are not present in blood, so leukocytes are only exposed to the LAIR ligands when they extravasate blood and enter tissues.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
Table 7. Human NK Cell Coreceptors
|
and β chains and may be of β1 and β2 types. LFA-1 is a β2 integrin (
L:β2; CD11a/CD18), which is expressed by NK cells and other leukocytes. It is involved in essential early steps in NK cell-mediated killing [136
]. It mediates contact and adhesion of NK cells with the target cell as well as polarization of cytoskeleton (actin and microtubules) and granules in NK cells toward the target cell [44
]. It is noteworthy that certain chemokines and cytokines (such as CCL-5, IL-2, and IL-15) as well as inside-out signaling from certain activating receptors (such as CD31) can induce conformational changes in LFA-1. These changes enhance affinity and avidity of the integrin for its ligands. Other β2 integrins expressed by NK cells include type III complement receptor (CR3; Mac-1;
M:β2; CD11b/CD18) and CR4 (
X:β2; CD11c/CD18). The β1 integrins expressed by NK cells include VLA-4 (
4β1; CD49d/CD29) and VLA-5 (
5β1; CD49e/CD29). They were named so because of their late expression in the course of T cell activation. Their ligands are indicated in Table 7
. NK cells use these molecules to interact with vascular endothelial cells. These interactions are important for NK cell extravasation and also regulate angiogenesis. The costimulation of NK cells via integrins usually facilitates their cytotoxicity and cytokine secretion. However, coligation of
4:β1 has also been implicated in the inhibition of CD16-mediated killing of NK cells [137
].
CD56 is an isoform of the N-CAM and is involved in homotypic cell adhesions. It is an IgSF member. The expression of CD56 on the surface of CD8+ T lymphocytes coincides with their acquisition of cytolytic potential [138
]. Twenty percent to 30% human (but not murine) NK cells express CD8 on their surface. This coreceptor stabilizes interaction of NK cells with target cells by binding with MHC [54
]. CD69 is an early marker of NK cell activation. Its expression correlates with the cytotoxic potential of NK cells. CD25 represents the IL-2R
chain. Its expression correlates with the proliferative capacity of NK cells in response to picomolar concentrations of this cytokine. CD27 is a member of the TNFR family. It binds transferin receptor (CD70) on target cells. CD44 binds hyaluronic acid on matrix proteins and facilitates LFA-1-mediated adhesion. CD59 is a GPI-anchored membrane glycoprotein, which physically interacts with NKp30 and NKp46 on the surface of NK cells. It is a complement regulatory protein and protects cells from death as a result of complement activation. It binds to the complement proteins C8a and C9. As a result of its physical association with the NCR, it transduces positive signals upon binding to its ligands and thus, acts as a coreceptor for NK cells.
Finally, resting fetal NK cells but not adult human NK cells express CD28, CD80 (B7.1), and CD86 (B7.2) as coreceptors.
The current model of NK cell function is based on the engagement of its inhibitory and activating receptors by their cognate ligands expressed on the surface of target cells. When an NK cell comes in contact with a target cell, inhibitory and activating receptors may bind with their cognate ligands expressed on the surface of the target cell. The balance between inhibitory and activating stimuli received by the NK cell determines whether it will kill or spare the target cell (Fig. 2) . Under physiological conditions, inhibitory signals usually remain dominant over activating ones. If for some reason, MHC class I expression is reduced on body cells, it may turn the balance of NK cell-received signals in favor of activating ones (as a result of loss of MHC-mediated inhibition of NK cells) and may make these cells susceptible to NK cell-mediated killing. Viral infections and malignancy may cause a reduction in the expression of MHC class I antigens on the surface of infected cells. That may explain, at least in part, why NK cells can kill virus-infected and cancer cells. However, it may be noted that a MHC-deficient cell is only killed if it expresses ligands for one or more activating NKRs. Furthermore, down-regulation of MHC expression by a target cell is not a prerequisite: It may become killed despite expressing normal levels of MHC antigens if it increases the expression of ligands for one or more activating receptors. Consequently, if target cells express NKG2D ligands de novo, the engagement of KIR may not be able to inhibit NK cell-mediated killing via NKG2D. If target cells express de novo NKG2D ligands and/or increase the expression of ligands for other NK cell-activating receptors as well as down-regulate the expression of MHC antigens, they would become super-susceptible to NK cell-mediated killing. The ligands for the activating NKG2D receptor may be induced on the body cells by viral infections, malignancy, or other stimuli causing genotoxic stress. Thus, NK cells sense not only the "missing or altered self" but also "induced self" to detect hazardous cells and kill them. It is noteworthy that different NK cell clones may vary in their ability to kill a given target cell. This ability depends on the repertoire of its activating and inhibitory receptors as well as its repertoire of signaling and effector molecules (perforin, FasL, etc).
A consequence of the stochastic expression of KIR genes is that each NK cell of an individual has a unique repertoire of expressed KIR. On the average, three to four KIR genes (inhibitory and activating ones) are expressed in an individual NK cell [146 147 148 ]. At least one of these receptors binds a self-MHC class I ligand and induces tolerance to self. The KIR genotype of an individual determines the repertoire of KIR expressed on his/her NK cells. The HLA genotype of the person affects this repertoire in a subtle way. The percent of expression of a KIR on NK cells of an individual is slightly increased if he/she also expresses an HLA ligand for that KIR [149 ]. A higher number of copies of an individual KIR allele also enhance its frequency of expression on NK cells. Furthermore, the number of other inhibitory KIR-HLA ligand pairs expressed in an individual also affects the expression of a given KIR on his/her NK cells; the higher the number, the lower the frequency. Therefore, it is not surprising that KIR haplotype identical sibling pairs with different MHC class I haplotypes have significant differences in the frequencies of expression of different KIR genes on their peripheral blood NK cells [150 ].
KIR and NKG2/CD94 receptors are usually expressed on mutually exclusive subsets of NK cells and complement each other (Table 2) . In the course of NK cell development and differentiation, NKG2/CD94 receptors are expressed earlier. Later in development, these receptors are replaced by KIR. However, a small proportion of NK cells continues to express NKG2/CD94 receptors and does not express KIR. In blood, CD56highCD16low NK cells usually express NKG2/CD94 receptors.
Although an individual NK cell may express three to four KIR genes, rarely does more than one of these receptors bind to a self-MHC antigen. Consequently, each individual NK cell can sense and respond to changes in individual MHC antigens on autologous cells. It would not have to wait until there is a global decrease in the expression of all MHC antigens. A distinct advantage of the clonal and variegated pattern of expression of KIR on NK cells is that different NK cells can sense different MHC class I antigens on target cells. NK cells in an individual may express certain KIR, which may not bind to any HLA antigen expressed by him/her. The individual may not have inherited HLA ligand genes for the receptor. For example, an individual may have a KIR2DL1 gene but may lack group II HLA-C genes, which encode its ligands. This may happen, as KIR and MHC class I genes are located on two separate chromosomes (12 and 6, respectively) and are assorted independently of each other.
The expression of KIR genes on NK cells usually remains stable and is least affected by cytokines. IL-21 plays a role in the induction of these receptors on developing NK cells from CD34+ progenitor cells in in vitro cultures [151 ]. The cytokine, however, does not affect KIR gene expression in mature NK cells. In contrast to KIR, cytokines may regulate expression of other NKRs. For example, IL-15, IL-10, and TGF-β1 were shown to induce expression of CD94/NK2GA on developing NK cells as well as on the TCR-stimulated CD8+ T cells. TGF-β1 also reduces expression of NKp30 and NKG2D on NK cells. IL-21 increases the expression of NCR and 2B4 on NK cells. The cytokine, however, decreases expression of NKG2D on NK cells as well as on CTL. Glucocorticoids also decrease NCR expression on NK cells [152 153 154 155 156 ]. These studies show that changes in cytokine production, which usually accompany viral infections and malignancy, may cause changes in the expression of different receptors on NK cells as well as on T cells. An altered expression of NKR has important implications for the functional activity of NK cells; it may lead to the emergence of autoimmune NK cell clones if inhibitory receptors on NK cells are reduced, and/or activating receptors are overexpressed. NK cells may also become immunodeficient if inhibitory receptors to MHC antigens are overexpressed on them. It has been demonstrated in the mouse model in vitro and in vivo that blocking NK cell inhibitory receptors by small molecular weight inhibitors or by receptor-specific antibodies increases NK cell activity against tumors and results in their regression [157 ]. The autoimmune cells may kill normal, autologous cells, whereas the immunodeficient ones may not be able to kill otherwise susceptible malignant or virus-infected cells. A dysregulated in vivo expression of KIR genes has been documented to cause immune deficiency in humans [120 ]. The authors described the case of a person who expressed KIR2DL1 on all of his NK cells. He was immunodeficient and suffered from repeated viral and bacterial infections.
-chain, and NKp46 [10
].
2.0 kb apart. The order of the genes in the LRC region has been deduced from sequencing of the KIR haplotypes as well from segregation analyses. KIR haplotypes vary in humans with respect to the number of activating and inhibitory genes as well as to their allelic forms. Because of these variations, a large number of KIR haplotypes have been identified. These haplotypes may be classified into two broad types: A and B. The type A haplotypes usually contain five inhibitory KIR genes. They also contain one S or activating KIR gene (KIR2DS4). This activating KIR, however, is frequently mutated and encodes a nonfunctional receptor as a result of the presence of a 22-bp deletion in exon 5 of the gene. About 80% of the Caucasians have this deletion [165
]. Therefore, type A haplotypes usually do not express a functional, activating KIR. They have an inherent tendency to strongly inhibit NK cells. Type B haplotypes are more diverse and may contain more (up to 14) KIR genes, which may include as many as five activating KIR (KIR2DS1,- 2, and -3, KIR2DS5, and KIR3DS1 but not KIR2DS4). It is noteworthy that all human KIR haplotypes contain KIR2DL4, which acts as an activating receptor despite having a long cytoplasmic tail. Figure 6
shows the prevalent KIR gene arrangements present in the most common A and B types of KIR haplotypes. Four KIR genes KIR3DL3, KIR3DP1, KIR2D4, and KIR3DL2 are present in all KIR haplotypes. Of these, KIR3DP1 is a pseudogene. These genes have been termed the "framework genes" [163
, 166
]. The frequencies of the two haplotypes vary significantly in different human populations. For example,
60% Japanese, 30% Caucasians, and 2% Australian Aborigines are homozygous for A haplotypes [166
, 167
]. It has been demonstrated that overall, 12% humans have predominantly inhibitory KIR genotypes (more inhibitory receptors than activating ones), and 36% have predominantly activating ones (more activating than inhibitory receptors). The rest (52%) have neutral KIR genotypes (equal number of activating and inhibitory KIR genotypes). Furthermore, only less than 1% of unrelated humans has the same KIR genes [168
]. In a small percentage of people, KIR may be truncated or unusually elongated. These inviduals may lack or may have duplicated copies of certain KIR genes. The KIR genotype of an individual greatly affects his/her NK cell responses to viral infections.
![]() View larger version (42K): [in a new window] |
Figure 6. Schematic representation of KIR haplotypes in humans. A haplotypes contain five inhibitory KIR and only one activating KIR (2DS4), which is frequently mutated. B haplotypes differ from A in having many activating KIR genes. The framework genes (3DL3, 3DP1, 2DL4, and 3DL2; in violet color) are present in each haplotype. The figure shows KIR genes present in the centromeric and telomeric halves of the frequently found A and B haplotypes above and below the framework genes, respectively. Each box in the figure represents a KIR gene. 3DP1 is a pseudogene.
|
Role of KIR3DL1 alleles
It is noteworthy that KIR3DL1 has 59 alleles, 12 of which encode the activating allotypes (KIR3DS1), and 47 encode inhibitory (KIR3DL1) allotypes. Depending on their level of expression on the cell surface, Martin et al. [75
] have divided the inhibitory allotypes into high expressors (KIR3DL1*001, *002, *008, *015, *009), low expressors (KIR3DL1*005, *007), and no expressor (KIR3DL1*004). The last one is retained within cells as a result of its truncated, cytoplasmic tail. They presumed that the affinities of these allotypes for their MHC ligands correlated with their expression levels. They further demonstrated that highly expressing KIR3DL1 alleles were protective when coinherited with HLA-Bw4-I alleles as compared with the low-expressing allotypes [75
]. This study also showed relative protection afforded by low-expressing KIR3DL1 alleles when coinherited with HLA-Bw4-T as compared with the individuals homozygous for Bw6 alleles. More surprisingly, KIR3DL1*004 also provided protection, despite the fact that this allotype is not expressed on the cell surface. This shows that even an intracellularly retained KIR3DL1 allotype may have functional significance. These results from Martin et al. [75
] suggest that the presence of a pair of inhibitory KIR3DL1 and its HLA ligand in HIV-infected persons affords protection from AIDS progression. Furthermore, the strength of the inhibition between the receptor-ligand pair correlates positively with the degree of protection. These results are not congruent with the paradigm that the KIR/HLA combinations that favored NK cell activation provided protection from viral infections and from the development of AIDS in HIV-infected individuals. The authors have argued that if NK cells were more strongly inhibited by KIR3DL1 receptor/ligand pairs, they would be more cytotoxic once they were relieved of their inhibition. The argument derives from the hypothesis that NK cells continue to express inhibitory KIR one after the other until they acquire sufficient inhibition to become self-tolerant. Thus, more tightly inhibited NK cells would be inherently more cytotoxic once their KIR/HLA-mediated inhibition is lost. The inhibition may be lost if the expression of HLA-Bw4 decreases on the surface of the virus-infected cells. Alternately, HLA-Bw4 may present a virus-derived peptide that may make it unrecognizable by the KIR3DL1 receptor. However, this argument cannot explain why coinheritence of KIR/HLA gene pairs, which inhibit NK cells rather loosely, or the inheritance of KIR without the genes for their HLA ligands protects humans from HIV and HCV infections [79
, 183
]. The authors have put forward another argument to explain their findings: In the presence of tightly inhibited NK cells, only a virus-specific, immune response is generated, avoiding a nonspecific, overall activation of the immune system. This response is more effective in suppressing HIV replication. Weakly inhibited NK cells may lead to a generalized activation of the immune response, which may cause immune-mediated pathology. However, there is no experimental evidence to support this argument. On the contrary, enhanced NK cell activation has been shown to induce better and stronger antigen-specific immune responses [184
]. Furthermore, it does not explain results from several other studies in which relatively weakly inhibited NK cells (as a result of weak-affinity KIR/HLA interactions) have been shown to provide protection from viral infections as well as from tumors [51
, 79
, 178
]. Even in the case of HIV infection, it has been reported that persons having weakly inhibited NK cells have reduced risk of contracting the infection. The study, conducted in African female sex workers, has shown that the inheritance of inhibitory KIR genes was protective from contracting HIV infection when the genes for their cognate MHC ligands were not coinherited. More specifically, KIR2DL2/3 heterozygotes without group I HLA-C and KIR3DL1 homozygotes without HLA-Bw4 were relatively protected [183
]. Furthermore, it has also been reported that the persons with KIR genotypes having more activating KIR genes were also relatively protected [183
, 185
]. In the case of i.v. drug users, stronger NK cell activities as well as a predominantly activating KIR repertoire (high KIR3DS1/KIR3DL1, NKG2C/NKG2A ratios, low expression of KIR3DL1, coinheritance of weakly inhibiting KIR/MHC pairs, i.e., KIR2DL3/HLA-C of group I) also protect from contracting HIV infection [185
, 186
]. Taken together, these studies suggest that weakly inhibited NK cells not only may slow progression of HIV infection toward AIDS but also may protect from contracting HIV infection. It is noteworthy that a hierarchy of KIR3DL1 allotypes for HLA-Bw4 binding has been described [149
] that differs significantly from the one used by Martin et al. [75
].
Concerning the impact of KIR3DS1 and its HLA ligands, Barbour et al. [187 ] have shown that the two genes affect AIDS progression independently from each other. The researchers analyzed viral load, CD4+ T cell counts, and KIR3DS1 and HLA-Bw4 genotypes of a cohort of 255 treatment-naïve, HIV-infected persons during the first 2 years of infection. They found that the KIR3DS1 and HLA-Bw4-I genes had distinct but independent effects on CD4+ T cell counts and viral loads, respectively. They noted that KIR3DS1-positive, HIV-infected persons maintained CD4+ T cells counts at higher levels as compared with the KIR3DS1-negative persons, irrespective of coinheritence of any Bw4-I alleles. The persons possessing HLA-Bw4-I alleles maintained lower viral loads all along the 2 years of the study period, irrespective of their KIR3DS1 status. In the persons having the receptor and the ligand genes, the effects on CD4+ T cell counts and viral load were simply additive and not synergistic. This study suggests a direct relationship between KIR3DS1 expression and CD4+ T cell counts in HIV-infected persons. It may be interesting to investigate potential interactions between KIR3DS1-positive NK cells and CD4+ T cells in humans. More recently, a direct role for an activating KIR, KIR3DS1, has been demonstrated in controlling HIV replication. In in vitro studies, KIR3DS1-positive NK cells inhibited HIV replication in HLA-Bw4-I-positive cell cultures in a contact and dose-dependent manner. The inhibition was significantly more as compared with KIR3DS1-negative NK cells [188 ]. Collectively, these studies do suggest a role of activated NK cells in controlling HIV infection. The caveat is that uncontrolled activation may contribute to immunopathogenesis.
It is noteworthy that HIV infections in humans have arisen relatively recently. The pathogen and its host have not had sufficient time to coevolve and eliminate deleterious genes from each other. Nevertheless, KIR and MHC antigens have evolved in humans under pressure from infectious agents, malignancy, and autoimmunity over millenia. Therefore, the impact of KIR genes, especially in combination with coinherited HLA genes on the susceptibility to HIV infection and development of AIDS in human populations, should be forthcoming. The studies conducted so far have yielded discordant results. The reasons for these discordant results may include variations in the pathogenicity of HIV viruses, treatment regimens, sample sizes, variable frequency of different genes in human populations, improper statistical models, etc. A part of the problem in formulating a uniform hypothesis regarding the impact of HLA/KIR interactions on the AIDS pathogenesis is the heterogeneous nature of the KIR with respect to their dependence on MHC-bound peptides. The two-domain KIR bind HLA-C and are affected by certain amino-acid side-chains at p7 and p8 of the MHC-bound nonamer peptides [83 ]. The three-domain KIR bind HLA-A and -B and are relatively more discriminating between the peptides bound to their MHC ligand Bw4. Their recognition may have implications for antiviral CTL responses. For example, if an individual has HLA-Bw4 alleles, he/she will be expressing KIR3DL1 on a subset of his/her NK cells, which will recognize HLA-Bw4 complexed with endogenous self-peptides and will be tolerant to them. If the individual becomes infected, his/her cells may bind a foreign (antigenic) peptide to its HLA. If the new peptide-bound HLA is recognized by KIR3DL1, the cell still will be protected from NK cells but may be killed by antiviral CTL. If the new HLA-peptide complex is not recognized by KIR3DL1, the cell will no longer be protected from KIR3DL1-positive NK cells. The HLA-peptide complex may, however, be recognized by the CTL, and the infected cell will also be killed by the CTL. Thus, NK cells and CTL will eliminate the infected cell. Thus, the person coinheriting KIR3DL1 and HLA-Bw4 may be better equipped to eliminate HIV-infected cells compared with the person who is homozygous for HLA-Bw6. It is noteworthy that KIR and TCR bind their cognate MHC ligands with much different kinetics and thermodynamic properties [189 , 190 ]. Therefore, if CTL and the KIR3DL1-positive NK cell recognize and bind the same Bw4-peptide complex, CTL may preclude the NK cell binding to the complex.
No KIR has been described that could bind HLA-Bw6 allotypes. Individuals bearing this HLA may be killed only by antiviral CTL (in the context of HLA-Bw6). It may explain why HLA-Bw4 and KIR3DL1 have synergistic effects in slowing down the progression of HIV toward AIDS (Fig. 7 ). As HLA-Bw4 homozygous persons are not likely to lack KIR3DL1, this may also explain why HLA-Bw4 homozygous individuals are relatively resistant to the development of AIDS as compared with HLA-Bw6 homozygous ones [75 , 176 ]. Furthermore, more protection may be afforded by high-affinity KIR3DL1 allotypes, as they may be more sensitive to the peptide requirements and therefore, may be less likely to recognize the HLA ligand if bound to a foreign peptide. However, at this point, it remains a speculation and needs to be proved by experimental data.
![]() View larger version (67K): [in a new window] |
Figure 7. NK cells with three-domain KIR behave like CTL in killing HIV-infected cells. (A) KIR3DL1 on NK cells recognize HLA-Bw4 with a self-peptide and are inhibited from killing normal, autologous cells. CTL do not recognize the self-peptide bound to the HLA and also do not kill the cell. (B) The virus-infected cell presents a virus-derived foreign peptide bound to HLA-Bw4. KIR3DL1 on the NK cell may not recognize the HLA with foreign peptide and is not inhibited from killing. The CTL may recognize the viral peptide bound to HLA-Bw4 and kill the infected cells. So, HIV-infected cells are more likely to be killed (from CTL as well as from NK cells). (C) KIR3DS1 expressed on NK cells does not bind to HLA-Bw4-I complexed with a self-peptide. CTL also do not recognize self-endogenous peptides and therefore, would not kill the healthy autologous cells. (D) A virus-infected cell presents a virus-derived foreign peptide bound to HLA-Bw4. It may be recognized by KIR3DS1 and be killed by KIR3DS1-positive NK cells. The CTL may also recognize the foreign peptide bound to HLA-Bw4 and therefore, will also kill the infected cell. Thus virus-infected, HLA-Bw4-positive cells are more likely to be killed (by virus-specific CTL and NK cells).
|
One should not overlook the fact that KIR are also expressed on T cells, especially on the memory/effector phenotype. This is an area that needs to be addressed in HIV immunology. Furthermore, one should also keep in mind that Nef may be attenuating the protective effects of KIR3DL1/Bw4 interactions by down-regulating the expression of these MHC antigens.
Role of HLA-G-binding KIR
As stated above, nonclassical MHC class I antigens, HLA-G and -E, also act as ligands for some NKRs. HLA-G binds KIR2DL4, ILT-2, and possibly KIR2DL5. The gene for HLA-G shows limited polymorphism. It was demonstrated that an HLA-G allele, HLA-G*0105N, which codes for a nonfunctional mutant HLA-G, provides protection from HIV infection in East African female sex workers. On the other hand, inheritance of functionally active HLA-G alleles increased the risk of the infection in these workers [192
]. It is noteworthy that HLA-G is expressed in the mucosal tissues of the female genital tract and may play a role in regulating local antiviral immunity. The authors interpreted the data by concluding that the mutant antigen protected women, as it could not inhibit their NK cells in the reproductive tract of the HIV-exposed women. Of the NKRs, which could bind HLA-G, KIR2DL4 is expressed on all CD56+ NK cells present in tissues in humans. However, as mentioned above in the KIR section, this receptor is not an authentic inhibitory KIR: It induces secretion of IFN-
but does not trigger cytotoxicity upon binding with its ligand [60
, 63
, 64
]. Two other receptors, ILT-2 and possibly KIR2DL5, may also bind and inhibit NK cell functions. However, they are only expressed on a minor subset of NK cells. Notably, monocytes, macrophages, and DC abundantly express different ILT, including ILT-2, which preferentially bind and are inhibited by HLA-G [97
]. Thus, in the persons having mutant HLA-G, activated monocytes, macrophages, and DC may play a greater role than NK cells. It has also been reported that the African women having a mutant HLA-E allele (HLA-E*0103-G or HLA-EG) have four times less risk of contracting HIV infection as compared with the women with wild-type HLA-E [193
]. It is noteworthy that the mutant HLA-E allele is expressed at lower levels and has decreased affinity for CD94/NKG2A receptors. It has also been shown that the sex worker women with HLA-E and HLA-G mutant genotypes (homozygous for HLA-EG as well as heterozygous for HLA-G*0105N) had more than 12-fold decreased risk of contracting HIV infection [193
]. These results implied a synergistic interaction between mutant HLA-E and HLA-G alleles in affording protection from HIV infection. These studies also suggest that blocking HLA-G and HLA-E interactions with NKR may enhance innate resistance to HIV.
Taken together, it can be postulated that coinheritance of genes for any NKR/ligand pair that weakens NK cell inhibition in the body and decreases activation threshold of NK and T cells is likely to provide protection from HIV and other viral infections. In this respect, the three-domain KIR behave as TCRs in recognizing MHC-bound peptides. If they fail to recognize the MHC-bound foreign peptide, they release the NK cell from inhibition. The NK cell will kill the virus-infected cell and so will do the virus-specific CTL. These two effector cells will be more effective in controlling HIV infection and delaying onset of AIDS in the persons who coinherit KIR3DL1/HLA-Bw4 genes. If the three-domain KIR also recognize the foreign peptide, then the NK cell will be inhibited from killing the target cell. These results have implication for HIV vaccine strategies. Viral peptides, which are recognized by CTL, but not by KIR3DL1, may serve as better immunogens. They may arouse NK and CTL responses for killing the infected cells.
In the case of HIV infection and AIDS, few studies conducted so far highlight the significance of HLA and KIR genes as well as of their interactions in determining our innate susceptibility to the infection and its progression to AIDS. Many of these studies lacked adequate sample sizes and did not take into account allelic variations. For example, all major KIR genes have allelic variants that encode nonfunctional receptors. Furthermore, different allotypes of a given KIR differ widely in their affinities for MHC ligands. Future studies should take into account the impact of these variants on the susceptibility/resistance of humans to the infection as well as on the rate of progression toward AIDS. The results could have a profound impact on our understanding of the role of NK cells in controlling HIV infection. In view of the large number of KIR genes, their alleles, differences in gene doses, and lack of knowledge about the ligands for activating KIR, the task of investigating the impact of KIR/HLA interactions on HIV infection is challenging but worth undertaking. The results would have enormous implications for the immunotherapy, prognosis, and vaccination of HIV infections. Such studies would require larger sample sizes, accurate clinical data, and proper stratification of study participants with respect to their ethnic backgrounds. Furthermore, the researchers must use models that include all KIR alleles and their ligand genes as well as all other known genetic determinants that affect host resistance to HIV infection.
In determining the role of genes for NKRs and those of their ligands, researchers have ignored the potential involvement of the ligands for KLR-D (NKG2D) receptors, i.e., MICA and MICB proteins, which exist in more than 50 and 20 allotypes, respectively. These allotypes vary in their affinity for NKG2D. The nature of the allotype(s) carried by an individual could greatly affect his/her NK cell ability to kill target cells. They have been shown to play a role in autoimmune diseases such as celiac disease, diabetes, etc.
Finally, research in this field is seriously hampered by lack of appropriate mAb to identify individual NKR genes and their allelic variants. Development of such reagents should be a priority. This would allow determining the level of expression of the genes at the protein level and supplement genetic data with more relevant protein data. Furthermore, these antibodies could serve as important tools for manipulating receptor/ligand interactions for therapeutic purposes.
Received September 24, 2007; revised February 25, 2008; accepted February 26, 2008.
-dependent and -independent initiation of switch recombination by NK cells J. Immunol. 167,2011-2018
}-defensin production Blood 104,1778-1783
} production J. Immunol. 175,1636-1642
} protein J. Immunol. 174,3859-3863
} production J. Immunol. 171,3415-3425
} production but not cytotoxicity by the killer cell Ig-like receptor KIR2DL4 (CD158d) in resting NK cells J. Immunol. 167,1877-1881
][β] T cells by NKG2D via engagement by MIC induced on virus-infected cells Nat. Immunol. 2,255-260[CrossRef][Medline]
production by human natural killer cells Mol. Immunol. 40,1157-1163[CrossRef][Medline]This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Iannello, S. Samarani, O. Debbeche, R. Ahmad, M.-R. Boulassel, C. Tremblay, E. Toma, J.-P. Routy, and A. Ahmad Potential Role of Interleukin-18 in the Immunopathogenesis of AIDS: Involvement in Fratricidal Killing of NK Cells J. Virol., June 15, 2009; 83(12): 5999 - 6010. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Bostik, J. Kobkitjaroen, W. Tang, F. Villinger, L. E. Pereira, D. M. Little, S. T. Stephenson, M. Bouzyk, and A. A. Ansari Decreased NK Cell Frequency and Function Is Associated with Increased Risk of KIR3DL Allele Polymorphism in Simian Immunodeficiency Virus-Infected Rhesus Macaques with High Viral Loads J. Immunol., March 15, 2009; 182(6): 3638 - 3649. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. S. Lee, W. O. Ward, D. C. Wolf, J. W. Allen, C. Mills, M. J. DeVito, and J. C. Corton Coordinated Changes in Xenobiotic Metabolizing Enzyme Gene Expression in Aging Male Rats Toxicol. Sci., November 1, 2008; 106(1): 263 - 283. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||